Examples of Evil in the World

Introduction

Religious atrocities—acts of violence explicitly justified, motivated, or exacerbated by religious beliefs—have scarred human history, often intertwining faith with political ambition, ethnic rivalries, and territorial conquests. While religion can foster peace and moral frameworks, it has also been weaponized to dehumanize “others” as heretics, infidels, or divine enemies, leading to mass killings and upheavals. Historian Matthew White, in “The Great Big Book of Horrible Things” (2011), ranks the 100 deadliest atrocities in history and identifies religion as the primary driver in just 11% (11 events), challenging the notion that faith is unusually violent compared to secular ideologies like communism or nationalism. Yet, these events alone account for tens of millions of deaths, with displacements often multiplying the human cost through famine, disease, and exile.

This overview focuses on eight of the deadliest, spanning the medieval to modern eras, selected for their scale and religious centrality. Estimates vary due to incomplete records, but they draw from scholarly consensus. Total deaths across these exceed 50 million; displacements, harder to quantify historically, likely surpass 100 million when including refugees, internal migrants, and forced resettlements. These figures underscore patterns: crusades as holy wars, inquisitions as purges of dissent, and partitions as faith-fueled divisions. The toll is not just numerical but cultural, erasing communities and fueling cycles of revenge.

Medieval Holy Wars: Crusades and Cathar Purges

The Crusades (1095–1291), a series of papal-sanctioned campaigns by Western Christians to reclaim Jerusalem from Muslim control, epitomize religion as a casus belli. Pope Urban II’s 1095 call framed the enterprise as divine penance, promising indulgences for participants. Eight major expeditions ravaged the Levant, Anatolia, and Iberia, pitting Latin Christendom against Islam, Judaism, and Eastern Orthodoxy. Massacres like the 1099 sack of Jerusalem—where Crusaders slaughtered thousands of Muslims, Jews, and even fellow Christians—highlighted the zeal. Atrocities extended to the Rhineland pogroms (1096), where mobs killed 2,000–12,000 Jews en route to the Holy Land, blaming them for Christ’s death.

Death toll: Approximately 3 million, including combatants, civilians, and indirect victims from famine and disease. Displacements: Hundreds of thousands fled the Holy Land; Muslim and Jewish populations in captured cities were expelled or enslaved, contributing to the depopulation of regions like Syria. The Crusades’ legacy included fortified outposts and enduring East-West animosities, but they ultimately failed, weakening Byzantium and inviting Mongol incursions.

Closely related was the Albigensian Crusade (1209–1229) against Cathar heretics in southern France, launched by Pope Innocent III to eradicate dualist beliefs viewing the material world as evil. What began as a targeted inquisition escalated into a royal land grab by France’s Capetian kings. The 1209 Béziers massacre saw 15,000–20,000 killed, with the papal legate infamously declaring, “Kill them all; God will know his own.” Cathars were burned alive, their strongholds like Montségur razed.

Death toll: 1 million, a staggering 20% of Languedoc’s population. Displacements: Tens of thousands of survivors scattered across Europe, with Occitan culture suppressed; refugees bolstered heretical movements in Italy and Bosnia. This “internal crusade” centralized French power but at the cost of regional genocide.

Early Modern Schisms: Wars of Faith in Europe

The Reformation’s fractures ignited Europe’s bloodiest intra-Christian conflicts. The French Wars of Religion (1562–1598) pitted Huguenots (Protestants) against Catholics in a cycle of sieges, assassinations, and massacres. St. Bartholomew’s Day (1572) alone saw 5,000–30,000 Huguenots slaughtered in Paris and beyond, sanctioned by royal edicts framing them as Lutheran threats to the realm. Queen Catherine de’ Medici’s plots and the Catholic League’s zeal prolonged the carnage, ending only with Henry IV’s Edict of Nantes (1598), granting limited tolerance.

Death toll: 3 million, including battle deaths and starvation. Displacements: Up to 1 million Huguenots fled to England, the Netherlands, and Prussia, seeding Protestant diasporas; internal refugees swelled urban slums, exacerbating plagues.

The Thirty Years’ War (1618–1648), ostensibly Protestant-Catholic but entangled in Habsburg ambitions, devastated Central Europe. Sparked by Bohemian defenestration and the Defenestration of Prague, it drew in Sweden, France, and Spain, turning the Holy Roman Empire into a charnel house. Armies lived off the land, spreading atrocities like the Magdeburg sack (1631), where 25,000 perished in rape, pillage, and fire. Lutheran pastor Peter Hagendorf’s diary chronicles cannibalism amid famine.

Death toll: 7.5–8 million, or 20–30% of Germany’s population, mostly civilians from disease and hunger. Displacements: 5–10 million refugees roamed, depopulating villages; Sweden absorbed thousands, while the Peace of Westphalia (1648) redrew maps, birthing modern sovereignty but leaving scarred wastelands.

Oliver Cromwell’s invasion of Ireland (1649–1653), rooted in Puritan anti-Catholicism, targeted Irish rebels as “barbarous” papists. After the 1641 Ulster uprising, Cromwell’s New Model Army razed Drogheda and Wexford, massacring 3,500–4,000 garrisoned troops and civilians. His regime confiscated lands, transplanting Catholic owners to Connacht’s “Hell or Connacht” bogs.

Death toll: 400,000–600,000 (15–40% of Ireland’s 1.5 million Catholics), via sword, plague, and famine. Displacements: 50,000–100,000 forcibly relocated; thousands emigrated to the Caribbean as indentured servants, embedding Protestant ascendancy for centuries.

Imperial and Modern Eras: Millenarian Rebellions and Ethnic Cleansings

The 19th century saw religion fuel anti-colonial and millenarian upheavals. The Taiping Rebellion (1850–1864) in Qing China, led by Hong Xiuquan—who claimed to be Jesus’s brother—blended Christianity with anti-Manchu fervor. Taiping forces seized Nanjing, establishing a theocratic “Heavenly Kingdom” with biblical laws banning opium and foot-binding. Civil war ensued, with Qing loyalists and Western-backed armies crushing the revolt in atrocities like the 1864 Nanjing reconquest.

Death toll: 20–30 million, history’s deadliest civil war, rivaling World War I. Displacements: Tens of millions internally uprooted; Yangtze Valley cities emptied, with refugees fueling banditry and depopulation.

The Mahdist War (1881–1899) in Sudan pitted Muhammad Ahmad’s Islamist followers—proclaiming a messianic jihad against “infidel” Egyptian-Ottoman rule—against British-Egyptian forces. The 1885 Khartoum siege killed General Gordon; Mahdi armies enforced sharia through crucifixions and enslavements.

Death toll: 5.5 million, from battles, famine, and rinderpest. Displacements: Over 1 million slaves and refugees; Nile Valley migrations reshaped demographics under Anglo-Egyptian reconquest.

The Armenian Genocide (1915–1923), during Ottoman collapse, targeted Christian Armenians as wartime traitors allied with Russia. Young Turk leaders orchestrated death marches, massacres, and concentration camps, with fatwas framing Armenians as “gâvur” (infidels). Over 1 million perished in Deir ez-Zor deserts.

Death toll: 1.5 million, halving Anatolia’s Armenian population. Displacements: 500,000–1 million survivors fled to Syria, Russia, and the Americas; it birthed the diaspora, with ongoing refugee crises.

Finally, the 1947 Partition of India divided British India into Hindu-majority India and Muslim Pakistan, unleashing communal riots. Leaders like Jinnah invoked Islamic destiny, while Gandhi’s secularism faltered amid mass hysteria. Trains arrived filled with corpses; Punjab’s canals ran red.

Death toll: 500,000–2 million. Displacements: 12–20 million, the largest migration in history; Hindus/Sikhs fled west, Muslims east, overwhelming borders with rape, arson, and orphan trains.

Conclusion: Patterns and Tallies

These atrocities reveal religion’s dual role: unifying aggressors while othering victims, often amplified by state power. Medieval crusades sanctified conquest; modern ones masked imperialism or nationalism. White’s tally for his 11 core events: ~45 million deaths. Adding Armenian and refined Partition figures pushes 50–55 million. Displacements are vaguer—Partition’s 15 million alone dwarfs others—but cumulative estimates (e.g., 10 million from Thirty Years/Taiping, 2 million from Crusades/Genocide) suggest 50–150 million over centuries, including uncounted internals.

Yet, context matters: Many “religious” wars had economic drivers, per White, comprising just 13% of history’s horrors versus 47% for conquests. Post-1945, international law (e.g., Genocide Convention) curbs overt faith-based violence, but echoes persist in Myanmar’s Rohingya crisis or ISIS caliphate. Remembering these fosters tolerance, reminding us that sacred texts, twisted, yield profane legacies. Total human cost: Immeasurable, but a call to vigilance.